Полнотекстовый поиск:
Где искать:
только в названии
только в тексте
слова в тексте
только заголовок

Рекомендуем ознакомиться

Остальные работы->Реферат
William Shakespeare was a great English playwright, dramatist and poet who lived during the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries Shakespeare...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
4 A young man started behaving in an aggressive and abusive manner after he had a number of alcoholic drinks at a party The next day he was behaving q...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
In John Locke s Essay of Human Understanding he successfully sets the foundation for disproving the doctrine of innate ideas through the use of severa...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
In Susan Glaspell?s Trifles, the dialog between characters creates the deep meaning of the story The attitudes of the men is much different than that ...полностью>>

Главная > Реферат >Остальные работы

Сохрани ссылку в одной из сетей:


The possible physical damage that could be done if human cloning became a reality is obvious when one looks at the sheer loss of life that occurred before the birth of Dolly. Less than ten percent of the initial transfers survive to be healthy creatures. There were 277 trial implants of nuclei. Nineteen of those 277 were deemed healthy while the others were discarded. Five of those nineteen survived, but four of them died within ten days of birth of sever abnormalities. Dolly was the only one to survive (Fact: Adler 1996). If those nuclei were human, “the cellular body count would look like sheer carnage” (Logic: Kluger 1997). Even Ian Wilmut, one of the scientists accredited with the cloning phenomenon at the Roslin Institute agrees, “the more you interfere with reproduction, the more danger there is of things going wrong” (Expert Opinion). The psychological effects of cloning are less obvious, but none the less, very plausible. In addition to physical harms, there! are worries about the psychological harms on cloned human children. One of those harms is the loss of identity, or sense of uniqueness and individuality. Many argue that cloning crates serious issues of identity and individuality and forces humans to consider the definition of self. Gilbert Meilaender commented on the importance of genetic uniqueness not only to the child but to the parent as well when he appeared before the National Bioethics Advisory Commission on March 13, 1997. He states that “children begin with a kind of genetic independence of [the parent]. They replicate neither their father nor their mother. That is a reminder of the independence that [the parent] must eventually grant them…To lose even in principle this sense of the child as a gift will not be good for the children” (Expert Opinion). Others look souly at the child, like philosopher Hans Jonas. He suggests that humans have an inherent “right to ignorance” or a quality of “separateness.” Hum! an cloning, in which there is a time gap between the beginning of the lives of the earlier and later twin, is fundamentally different from homozygous twins that are born at the same time and have a simultaneous beginning of their lives. Ignorance of the effect of one’s genes on one’s future is necessary for the spontaneous construction of life and self (Jonas 1974). Human cloning is obviously damaging to both the family of and the cloned child. It is harder to convince that non-human cloning is wrong and unethical, but it is just the same. The cloning of a non-human species subjects them to unethical treatment purely for human needs (Expert Opinion: Price 97). Western culture and tradition has long held the belief that the treatment of animals should be guided by different ethical standards than the treatment of humans. Animals have been seen as non feeling and savage beasts since time began. Humans in general have no problem with seeing animals as objects to be used whenever it becomes necessary. But what would happen if humans started to use animals as body for growing human organs? Where is the line drawn between human and non human? If a primate was cloned so that it grew human lungs, liver, kidneys, and heart., what would it then be? What if we were to learn how to clone functioning brains and have them grow inside of chimps? Would non-human primates, such as a chimpanzee, who carried one or more human genes via transgenic technology, be defined as still a chimp, a human, a subhuman, or something else? If defined as human, would we have to give it rights of citizenship? And if humans were to carry non-human transgenic genes, would that alter our definitions and treatment of them(Deductive Logic: Kluger 1997)? Also, if the technology were to be so that scientists could transfer human genes into animals and vice-versa, that would heighten the danger of developing zoonoses, diseases that are transmitted from animals to humans. It could create a world wide catastrophe that no one would be able to stop (Potential Risks). In conclusion, the ethical and moral implications of cloning are such that it would be wrong for the human race to support or advocate it. The sheer loss of life in both humans and non-humans is enough to prove that cloning would be a foolish endeavor, whatever the cause.

Works Cited

h Kluger, Jeffery. “Will we Follow the Sheep?” Time Magazine. March 10, 1997 Vol. 149 No.10

Загрузить файл

Похожие страницы:

  1. Cloning 9 Essay Research Paper Should humans

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning 9 Essay, Research Paper Should humans be cloned? A Time Magazine poll (March 10, ... , March 17, 1997, vol.11, #6:p.1-6. Adult cloning might appeal to those who ... has imposed a moratorium on human cloning research (March 4, 1997). Meanwhile, several ...
  2. Cloning 7 Essay Research Paper CloningThe announcement

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning 7 Essay, Research Paper Cloning The announcement one year ago that Scottish scientists had successfully cloned ... for Cloning Humans. Webcrawler: 33 pp. Netscape. Internet. 11 Feb. ... 1998. Available best.com/ vere/cloning.htm Woods ...
  3. Cloning 8 Essay Research Paper Cloning Cloning

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning 8 Essay, Research Paper Cloning Cloning is the production of a group ... of federal money for then research of cloning humans all make it ... (1988) Setlow, J., Genetic Engineering, vol. 11 (1989) Williams, J., and Patient, R., Genetic ...
  4. Cloning Issue Essay Research Paper Genesis

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning Issue Essay, Research Paper Genesis 11:1-9 records the sad ... be refined through further research." Second, no one ... and iniquity that human cloning presents. Cloning is just not ... reasons. First, cloning results in abortions. Cloning is a complicated ...
  5. Cloning Essay Research Paper Before we assume

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning Essay, Research Paper Before we assume that the market for human clones consists mainly ... too much about their animal-cloning research, much less their work ... people are saying: At 11:50 AM John said: ... needs to be monitered. At 11:52 AM George W. said: ...
  6. Cloning Essay Research Paper Comments by Individuals

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Cloning Essay, Research Paper Comments by Individuals, ... -vitro fertilization, or cloning…If cloning research is banned, millions ... child abuse and murder.” 11 Randolfe Wicker founded Clone ... should not interfere with cloning research: “Cloning, like all science, ...

Хочу больше похожих работ...

Generated in 0.0025670528411865