Главная > Реферат >Остальные работы
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper
Bilingual Education Faces Uphill Fight Summer was good to Ron Unz, the California crusader against bilingual education. Not only is he happy with his state’s test results–which he says show his English-immersion education plan is working–but a similar proposal he’s backing in Arizona was guaranteed a place on that state’s ballot in November.
Flush with optimism, the Silicon Valley multimillionaire has ignored naysayers: Unz’s stats, his opponents charged, were selective and soft, just as they had been in 198 when his proposal was approved by the voters. But lack of agreement about statistics didn’t stop approval of Proposition 227 by California voters grappling with a soft economy, a tide of immigrants and a call to hold teachers accountable for students’ poor academic performance. Unz’s law replaced the state’s bilingual education program with a one-year English immersion program, except for those students whose parents request a waiver.
For his new drive in Arizona, Unz has artillery he didn’t have in California–new, favorable test results and an organized, Hispanic-led group to campaign for his cause. “It’s unwise to take an approach where you don’t have strong and credible local support,” says Unz, a software entrepreneur. If Proposition 203 succeeds in Arizona, Unz expects to march east with similar plans, to states such as Massachusetts and New York with especially vocal debates over the merits of bilingual education.
“I don’t see any other way for chance,” says Unz, who lost a gubernatorial bid in 1994 and considered running for Dianne Feinstein’s Senate seat this year. “I don’t think politicians are going to do anything about it. Politicians are extraordinary
But bringing the debate to the polls–politicizing it–carries dark overtones, according to Delia Pompa, executive director of the National Association for bilingual Education, “[Bilingual education] has become an easy scapegoat for people nervous about immigration, people who have xenophobic tendencies,” she says. “It’ll be important to look toward Arizona to see what precedent is set there,” says Roberto Rodriguez, education reform coordinator for the National Council of La Raza. “We’re concerned with these initiatives that we feel are not related to the best interests of the education of children, but have more to do with external issues.”
The Arizona law would replace bilingual education with one year of English immersion, unless parents could prove a child’s social and psychological need for dual-language classes. Some Arizonans particularly fear a provision in the law that would give school the power to refuse, without explanation, a parent’s request for bilingual classes. “It’s taking away the power of parents to choose,” says.
Alejandra Sotomayor, southern Arizona cochairman of the Arizona Language Education Council, formed in response to the initiative drive.
- ... on racism to counter attack the views of its ... conducted by the NRC (National Research Council), and by other ... the state board of education to continue bilingual education. On June 3, 1998 a ... over parental waivers foe children under ten with “special needs”. ...
- ... the Francophone daily paper, Le Devoir. ... Provide more schools and education facilities. - Provide jobs ... 1962 Lesage campaigned under the slogan “ ... servants learning french. Bilingualism was a symbol ... each other. The basic function of NORAD is to detect any attack ...
- ... Coloreds. More Afrikaners are bilingual than English-speakers. ... for other races. Education has been under the control of a ... multiracial, tricameral legislature. Each chamber exercises authority over the ... for years continued to attack European soldiers before ...
- ... according to archaeological research, attained its ... the viceroy, under pressure from influential ... chief executive of each state is a ... Gamble, Scott Paper and Zenith all ... They demand bilingual and intercultural education in their ... off a diabetic attack which kept ...
- ... processes and instruction, writing, bilingualism, bilingual education, translation, pragmatics, discourse ... of linguistic research underlying each concept. Enormous ... EFL) has come under attack for reasons other ... on a piece of paper specifically what linguistic ...