Поиск

Полнотекстовый поиск:
Где искать:
везде
только в названии
только в тексте
Выводить:
описание
слова в тексте
только заголовок

Рекомендуем ознакомиться

Остальные работы->Реферат
A baby was born on July 12 or 13 of 100 BC in Rome. Little did the proud parents of this baby know that he would rule most of the known world. This ba...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
Sex plays a major role in today’s society. It seems that all forms of media use sex to help sell their products. From television, radio, music, and ad...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
The other night I was takin’ the trash out. I heard ol’ Bessie, my cow carryin’ on like there was a snake in her pin. I ran over and I said “Bessie, y...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
What Benjamin Franklin meant by this does not only apply back during his day, but it applies throughout history. This quote can apply to the history o...полностью>>

Главная > Реферат >Остальные работы

Сохрани ссылку в одной из сетей:

In Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie goes through several relationships before “[s]he pulled in her horizon like a great fish net. Pulled it from around the waist of the world and draped it over her shoulder” (p. 184). In other words, not all the experiences that helped her to gain control of her life were positive ones. These experiences can be put into one of four relationships: Nanny, Logan Killicks, Jody Starks, and Tea Cake.

No doubt that Nanny loved Janie a great deal, and naturally she wanted her granddaughter to have security beyond an old woman who would inevitably die. She also wanted more opportunities for Janie than she’d had as she grew up a slave. As she explains to Janie, “[a]nd Janie, maybe it wasn’t much, but Ah done de best Ah kin by you. Ah raked and scraped and bought dis lil piece uh land so you wouldn’t have to stay in de white folks’ yard and tuck yo’ head befo’ other chillun at school” (p. 19).

Nanny’s intentions are only to make Janie’s life better than hers was, but in an ironic twist she is the one who puts the shackles on Janie in the first place by marrying her off to the person, not of Janie’s choice, but of her own. To give Janie a better life than a slave, Nanny would have done better to not be as controlling. Unfortunately, Janie seems only to remember this and not Nanny’s love.

Here Nanny had taken the biggest thing God ever made, the horizon-for no matter how far a person can go the horizon is still way beyond you-and pinched it in to such a little bit of a thing that she could tie it about her granddaughter’s neck tight enough to choke her. She hated that old woman who had twisted her so in the name of love. (p.85)

Logan Killicks then takes Nanny’s place in Janie’s life. Even for her controlling Nanny he is a poor substitute at best as he calls her spoiled and talks down to her. At one point he even criticizes her for being “powerful independent” (p. 29) for someone who had been born the way she had (as if she had a choice in the matter!).

If Logan did genuinely care about Janie, then it could not have been a much more complex feeling than his wanting his tools or his mule around. But human beings are a great deal more complicated than that and (hopefully) are not satisfied with being considered a thing rather than a person. Logan goes to town to get a new mule and is expecting that Janie will automatically work with him, something she happens not to agree with. Logan’s problem is that he has a set of expectations about Janie and she fails to live up to them. Had Logan been wiser, he would not have built himslef up so much and instead appreciated who Janie was and not who she wasn’t. This is the last straw in a strained relationship.

Jody Starks has ambition, which is probably not the thing that least attracts Janie to him. In any case, she leaves Logan Killicks to start a new relationship with Jody.

Jody is the first person to hit Janie, and in general he treats her as if she were his property. She is made to tie up her hair, for instance, so that no one else in town can see her with it down. He tries to maintain her as a thing that no one else may look upon or take pleasure from, therefore he keeps control over her life. Ambition may have attracted Janie to Jodie, but the thing he loves is power, and even at his most sensitive to her he is still a shrewd man who’s real intentions have to be second guessed at.

One perplexing thing about Janie’s relationship with Jody is why she doesn’t leave. She certainly shows that she has the initiative when she leaves Logan Killicks, and by the time Jody has hit her for accidentally ruining their dinner it seems obvious that this is not a healthy relationship. So why does Janie stay? Probably because there is no one to latch on to immediately, like there was when she was with Logan Killicks. This greatly qualifies the reader’s optimism since it is showing that Janie is really not so independent- even with the verbal assaults she launches back at Jody, she still stays with him until he dies.

Tea Cake is the only man to ever court Janie (what Logan Killicks did with Nanny is more like lobbying his cause). He is fun-loving, high spirited, outgoing, and does not act like he owns or wants to own her. These things make Tea Cake the ideal mate for Janie, and her relationship with him is the only one that she really enjoys being a part of consistently.

What is bothersome about Tea Cake is that he does in fact hit Janie. Apparently this was tolerable, and even expected at the time. In today’s society it would certainly not be tolerated, nor would the attitude that goes along with it. Tea Cake hits Janie because he is weak, and the act has the complete opposite effect on the reader from the effect it has on the characters in the novel.

When Mrs. Turner’s brother came and she brought him over to be introduced, Tea Cake had a brainstorm. Before the week was over he had whipped Janie. Not because her behavior justified his jealousy, but it relieved that awful fear inside him. Being able to whip her reassured him of possession. No brutal beating at all. He just slapped her around to show her who was boss. (p. 140)

Maybe it isn’t the beating that is such a problem, but the fact that he needed to be reassured of possession when it is all but assumed that tea Cake is different from the rest of the characters who had tried to possess and/or control Janie.

At her trial, Janie is silent either by Hurston’s wanting to tell it in omniscient third person, or because Hurston is, in fact, trying to qualify the reader’s total optimism about Janie’s life. Was Janie unable to achieve her voice as Robert Stepto contends (see Forward, xi)? Or did we the readers not hear Janie defend herself because knowing how to use your voice includes knowing when not to as Alice Walker believes? Or is Mary Helen Washington the one who hits the nil on the head when she writes, “I think that silence reflects Hurston’s discomfort with the model of the male hero who asserts himself through his powerful voice.” Depending on the reader’s interpretation of the book, it could be any of these things. But the fact remains that it can be interpreted all three ways (and possibly more) and that alone is enough for the reader to question whether or not the novel is purely optimistic.


Загрузить файл

Похожие страницы:

  1. The Decline Of The Roman Empire Essay

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... , lead to the inevitable failure of the Republic. As to the question of whether or not ... , the ever expanding power and influence of conquering generals played a great part in the collapse of the ...
  2. The Pressures Of Patco Strikes And Stress

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... minimize the role of controllers, though, actually conflicted with the development of optimal technical ... in reality, disputes over more fundamental questions of power and job security. The ... control was not a question of profit, but in fact posed a blatant ...
  3. Red Freedom The Application Of Reformed Socialism

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... poor people. (The exception to this of course being the differences between the ruling clique of the ... directly interventionary”. On the question of state involvement in the economy, this is ... them, the optimal output could have been achieved. In this scenario ...
  4. The Battle For Campaign Agenda In Britain

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... given the outcome. The question, in the long run-up to the election, was whether the Tory ... degree of optimism that is not entirely justified by the evidence”. The paper was ... may provide a poor indication of interest, since the size of the audience for news ...
  5. The Future Of The Race Essay Research

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... the black community and that the authors in question possess authority to speak for the ... games, emerging from the crucible of black power with his humanity intact ... faith in Enlightenment or Victorian values. They resisted the temptation of optimism. Despite ...

Хочу больше похожих работ...

Generated in 0.0012898445129395