Поиск

Полнотекстовый поиск:
Где искать:
везде
только в названии
только в тексте
Выводить:
описание
слова в тексте
только заголовок

Рекомендуем ознакомиться

Остальные работы->Реферат
As children move into early adolescence they grow and develop, and involvement with their peers and the need for peer identification increases. (Lingr...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
Doctors have long recognized that breastfed infants contracted far fewer infections than infants who were given formula. The reason is that mother s m...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
W.E.B. Dubois believed that, ?The Negro race…is going to be saved by its exceptional men.? By this he meant that the most educated of the blacks will ...полностью>>
Остальные работы->Реферат
The American settlers had early become used to taking a share in government. Every colony elected an assembly. The Virginians set up their House of Bu...полностью>>

Главная > Реферат >Остальные работы

Сохрани ссылку в одной из сетей:

Steps Towards An Ecosociety: Dealing With Air Pollution Essay, Research Paper

Steps Towards an Ecosociety: Dealing with Air Pollution

By: Jonathan Roitman

For: Dr. Rao

Course: Poli 385/2

This essay identifies and explains the problem of pollution facing

humanity today. It will also propose one of the first ideas which could more

effectively limit air pollution, Emission Credit Trading. This can be seen as

one of the first steps in the development of an ecosociety. The notion of a

viable ecosociety has created considerable problems in terms of deciding the

most effective and efficient policies to be implemented. Air pollution has

become one of the most serious environmental problems here at home, and

throughout the rest of the world. Air pollution is also perhaps one of the more

politically sensitive problems because of the numerous economic, environmental

and health implications involved.

A key step in the policy-making process is to define the problem to be

remedied. If we can not understand the problem, how are we to know what needs to

be fixed. Unfortunately, implementing policies on air pollution has the

politically undesirable effect of having extensive economic consequences on all

sectors of the economy. Therefore, those policies which lead to the development

of an ecosociety must be aimed at having the greatest environmental impact while

creating minimal economic distortions.

For the purpose of this essay, pollution shall be identified as follows

“…the deliberate or accidental introduction to the environment of contaminants,

in the form of either wastes or products ” (Bryner, 10). This essay will deal

with the problem of air pollution. Air pollutants come from heavy industry,

fumes from automobiles, jet planes and the like. When speaking of the automobile

alone “…each gallon of gas burned releases 22 pounds of carbon dioxide in the

atmosphere…the car is the single largest contributor to global warming ”

(Rifkin 179). Although the majority of the problem areas are in the developing

world, these areas can affect the entire world. The atmosphere is not confined

to borders like the land. Pollution spreads beyond the borders of any country,

and as such, no one region can solve the problem alone. In some developing

nations, there are areas that people and animals cannot live in for extended

periods of time.

One visitor to the Romanian ‘black town’ of Cops Mica noted that “the

trees and grass are so stained by soot that they look as if they had been soaked

in ink.” A local doctor reported that even horses can stay only for two years in

the town; “then they have to be taken away, or else they will die” (Gore 81).

There are many reasons that pollution has come to the foreground of

twentieth century politics. The most important is the effect it has on human

life. This does not place the effects that it has on our natural environment as

secondary, however, it seems that unless we as human beings are directly

affected, we tend to look the other way.

The EPA’s 1990 report on urban air quality trends estimates that over

100 million Americans live in areas where pollution exceeds federal air quality

standards, as well air pollution is responsible for more then 50,000 to 60,000

premature deaths each year (Bryner, 3)

Air pollution is also the main cause of global warming and the

depletion of the ozone layer. If the earth’s temperature rises by a mere five

degrees, the resulting catastrophe would be immeasurable. It is important to

realize that global warming is a direct result of the depletion of ozone in the

atmosphere.

“A greater variety of greenhouse gases are created by a myriad of

essential human activities, including the generation of power, industrial

production, transportation, agriculture and forestry. Mitigating climate change

will require major changes in life-style, especially those that consume large

amounts of fossil fuels” (Vig and Kraft 313).

We can see that no matter where we look, air pollution has come to

occupy a major part in our daily lives. The only way to reduce the quantity of

poisonous emissions to the air would require a drastic change in the way we live.

Due to inefficient regulatory policies, the different types of air

pollution pose severe problems. Air pollution occurs when “gases and

particles are combined or altered in such a way that they degrade the air and

form substances that are harmful to humans, animals, and other living things

(Bryner, 41).” Some air pollution is a result of natural processes such as

forest fires, volcanoes or wind blown dust. Conversely, the majority of

pollutants are the direct result of human interaction and misuse of our

environment. An example of this is the loss of the whales, who for centuries

lived in the St. Lawrence region of the Atlantic Ocean, but had to migrate due

to the “…polluted water emptying out of the Great Lakes. They are said to be

contaminated with toxic chemicals at concentration levels high enough that they

are technically classified as hazardous waste” (Keller, 262).

“…the atmosphere will…need to be regulated as a global trust if the

human community is to entertain any possibility of addressing the problems of

global warming, ozone depletion, acid rain, and air pollution. In June 1988, the

prime ministers of Norway and Canada proposed a “Law of the Air” treaty to

protect the atmosphere from global warming and ozone depletion.[The end result

being]…the transition to renewable energy sources, and the research and

development of alternatives to CFCs” (Rifkin 318).

Air pollution and pollution in general have reached such alarming levels

because of human neglect and ignorance. They have been allowed to perpetuate due

to the lack of clearly defined property rights within the ecosphere (natural

resources and the environment). We must realize that individual actions as well

as those of large and /or small corporations affect not only the lifestyle, but

the quality of life of all organisms on the planet; human or not. “The

corporation’s inherent tendency to maximize profits by mass-production and

technological efficiency clashes with the desire to limit material growth and

preserve nature” (Arnopoulos 150). We must recognize the consequences our

actions have on the environment or we are doomed to keep on repeating our

mistakes.

Another example could be what has become known as the Dust Bowl of the

1930’s. “Perhaps the largest forced migration in American history was the mass

departure from Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, parts of New Mexico, Colorado, Nebraska

and other plains during the period of the early 1930’s… (Gore 71). The Dust

Bowl resulted in huge sand storms as the farmland of the above mentioned areas

became completely devastated as a result of the overuse of its agricultural

ability. It was pushed to far, and the exploitation finally ended in rendering

the land useless for decades.

The protection of the environment has become a major concern in all

levels of political, social and economic arenas. As we enter the next millennium

we must ask ourselves what type of environment do we want to live in? How do we

want our children to grow up? The practical answers to these questions are

difficult, but not the theoretical ones. Theoretically, the perfect world is one

in which we do not have to fear pollution, we do not have to be afraid of the

water we drink, or the air we breath. Unfortunately, this is not a perfect world

and we have no choice but to worry.

The idyllic world outlined above is what ecologists and social

scientists alike hope for: an ecosociety. This ecosociety is sought after by so-

called Green Parties. There are six key strategies which they employ (through

different tactical means) in order to achieve their policies. They are: to think

globally by acting locally. The reason for this is to attempt to spread some

sort of global awareness, but get citizens involved at a local level, hence

having them feel that they are playing a key role and are important in the

policy making process. Green parties also advocate more ecological education,

and a more sustainable economy. This notion of a more sustainable economy can be

achieved the following ways: conservation of resources, slow down material

production, and lower industrial output. What this all amounts to is moving the

tertiary and quaternary sectors of the economy to the fore, and eliminating the

primary and secondary (to a literally subsistence level). Furthermore, they want

to get h uman beings to recognize the highly spiritual life that they are

capable of living and not the hedonistic material one they are living. By the

same token, they want to increase green spaces and partake in long range

planning thereby helping to keep the earth alive as long as possible (Arnopoulos,

92). By concentrating on the above six strategies, Green Parties believe that it

may be possible for people to change from a consumed to a conserved society. A

society in which we live in harmony with nature, not in dominance over it.

As we look back today and see the damage that has been done to the

environment, we wonder what went wrong. That question could be answered as such:

“The thoughtless and shortsighted transformation of scientific knowledge into

technical know-how has given mankind too much power too soon to be able to use

it wisely (Arnopoulos 80)”. With these technological advances comes the

inevitable depletion and deterioration of the earth. Depletion, in the sense

that we are undoubtedly going to run out of natural resources at our present

rate of consumption. Deterioration, in the sense of all the pollutants which we

constantly spew into our environment , where our children and theirs will have

to live.

Public opinion polls show wide spread support for stronger and more

aggressive measures aimed at solving pollution problems and protecting our

natural resources. These sentiments have become so pervasive that well over the

majority of people believe that “protecting the environment is so important that

requirements and standards cannot be too high, and continuing environmental

improvements must be made regardless of cost (Mitchell, 85).” This mass

popularization of environmentalism has had the effect of increasing demands for

action being made on our political process and leaders.

In many industries, air pollution is a by-product of normal economic

production. In some such cases government authorities have restricted firms’

production of effluents. This restriction is often imposed as a maximum rate of

flow at which a firm may emit pollutants. This system in which emissions are

managed on a source to source basis has been labeled one of “Command-and-Control

(Vig and Kraft, 52).” However, empirical studies have shown that costs under

Command-and-Control mechanisms are as much as twenty times as expensive as the

least-cost market oriented mechanism that achieves the same environmental

quality. This discrepancy in efficiency is due to the high costs associated

with regulating the C&C method since allocations must be made on a firm to firm

basis. As well, even when all sources are in compliance with technological

based standards, there is no guarantee that the sum of emissions will produce

quality air.

Recently, there is growing consensus that the methods of control do not

work on a uniform basis in terms of addressing different locations and types of

pollutants with the most damaging health impacts. Presently, standards refer to

ambient (outdoor) concentrations where measurements can most easily be made,

most often from the tops of buildings. However, in North America we spend under

10% of our time outdoors, and even less atop buildings. As negligible as this

may appear to be, the exposure to pollutants which one receives varies greatly

from being indoors, at street levels or on top of a high-rise. With particular

pollutants, as little as 25% of total exposure is due to outdoor exposure. This

is due to many of the air pollutants (environmental tobacco smoke, household

chemicals…) which in terms of total levels are minimal, but because of the

quantities we are exposed to have the greatest impact on human health (Saunders,

277-8).

The implicit assumption underlining ECT is that health damages from

pollution depend only on the effects of emissions on widespread ambient

concentrations. Local effects are for the most part ignored. Consequently,

sources of pollution that may have substantial effects on a local level but a

negligible effect on ambient ones are not taken into account. With this in mind

Emission Credit Trading could be considerably improved, in terms of the impact

it is to have on health and environmental conservation, by shifting from

concentration to exposure levels (Saunders, 276).

There is also the question of legitimate enforcement. The arbitrary

nature of enforcement in such a system as C&C creates an environment in which

polluters have an incentive to be rent seeking competitors. And with the status

of our political and administrative offices this can produce the perception of

favoritism or in some cases corruption. Since rent seeking is economically

inefficient, and it increases the publics (already high) cynicism about

government, a decentralized Emission Credit Trading program would minimize these

problems. ECT programs have been advanced as a major improvement over command-

and-control pollution abatement programs. This is one of the first pieces of

proposed legislation toward an environmentally friendly shift in politics. The

entire concept of Emission Credit Trading is bringing to the fore the notion

that we do live in a sort of ‘Global Village’ and that the “… importance of a

system is proportional to the degree it can affect its environment… the

sensitiv ity of a system depends on how much it is affected by its environment.

If the sensitivity is high, the system is dependent on the environment; if low,

independent” (Arnopoulos 45). We are now realizing that we cannot act completely

independently from nature, because we are all related. We cannot be sustained

without nature. The administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency went

as far as to proclaim transferable discharge permits “the most important

innovation in environmental policy for the next decade” (Rifkin, 66).

As previously mentioned, the major contributor to air pollution is the

automobile. Therefore, any thought of policy dealing with the elimination or

reduction of air pollution should concentrate, but not be limited to the

automobile. In dealing with the automobile in terms of reducing it’s impact on

air pollution incentives must be given for manufacturers to reduce pollutant

emissions from their vehicles and the costs associated with the pollution

created from driving must be transferred to those people operating the vehicle.

To increase manufacturers compliance with the production of less harmful

vehicles, a combination of averaging and trading is the most effective solution.

This system is very similar to that of Emission Credit Trading in that

manufactures will be given a fleet wide average standard to meet (ie: their

sales-weight emissions can’t exceed the average). This average can then be met

in two manners. By averaging emissions within their fleet, through methods such

as installing pollution reduction equipment on their vehicle or by altering

their sales mix towards more fuel efficient vehicles. Or the manufacturer can

trade emission allocations with other manufactures in the same manner as ECTs

(Bryner, 176). It is important to note here that this is a different proposal as

to what is already in existence.

The second method by which automobile pollution can be reduced focuses

on internalizing the costs of pollution into the driving experience. The most

effective and efficient manner is in the development of electronic scanning

devices that would locate a vehicle at suitable points along the road and then

monthly billings would be sent to the owner based on the vehicle’s contribution

to congestion. To increase fairness (due to different emission levels of

vehicles) this can be combined with periodic inspections so as to determine

emission levels of a particular vehicle, so as to adjust billings accordingly

(Bryner, 5). A serious increase in fuel taxes would also not do any harm in

reducing air pollution problems. It is important to note that by putting the

costs of pollution onto drivers this will increase pressures on manufactures to

produce more efficient cars, and develop alternative fuel sources.

In a nutshell emission credit trading programs operate as follows.

Rather than having each firm reduce it’s emissions by a given amount, the

program requires that average emissions be reduced by a set amount. A firm that

reduces it’s emissions below this average level would be given credits which

could be sold or saved. Credits which are saved could then be used at a later

date if the firm desired to increase production (hence pollution). Credits to

be sold would go to firms finding it less costly to purchase credits at market

rates than to actually reduce harmful emissions. Therefore, each firms

incentive to invest in more effective pollution abatement technology will

increase. Through the trading of credits, dollars spent on pollution control

are spent where they are most effective at reducing pollution.

Some of the advantages of ECT’s are that no other method is as effective

at allocating the decision making process to the people who are in the position

to devise the best balance between the advantages and disadvantages of various

methods of reducing polluting emissions. There are different methods by which a

firm can reduce its pollution, most often being directly tied into complicated

technological processes unique to its operations or industry. Consequently,

unless the cooperation of management and technicians within the industry or

activity can be effectively mobilized by self-interest motivation, it is

unlikely that the best solution will be attained (Gore, 1).

In addition, as mentioned earlier, nearly all other methods of reducing

air pollutants involve a degree of arbitrary decision making on the part of

officials charged with administering controls. Such controls may be necessary

to even the best ECT system, but if administered in conjunction with such a

system then the necessary discriminations will at least be minimized. In such a

case when controls need to be imposed, they will be done (if not in practice at

least in perception) in a much more unilateral manner. This eliminates the

perception of arbitrariness and discrimination, which in turn leads to greater

levels of compliance and cooperation amongst corporations (Gore, 2).

Furthermore, a system of Emission Credit Trading is at least in

principle, highly flexible, in that the market price will vary in accordance

with changing circumstances, even changing weather conditions . Technically,

this may be difficult to incorporate immediately, but the potential for

development is present.

Perhaps most importantly, the use of ECT forces the air pollution

problem to be brought into perspective. Once transnational corporations take a

stake in the problem, an ecosociety becomes more plausible. The reason for this

is because of the power that they yield, and the influence which they are

capable of spreading. Pollution costs shall also be internalized into the cost

of production. This has the effect of greater adoptions of emission reduction

technology, since there is a monetary incentive to do so. And with the

increasing levels of global competitiveness these transnational corporations (as

well as local firms) can not afford to ignore any forms of cost reductions. As

well, in this day of information highways and increased consumer awareness firms

which adopt environmentally sound practices are much likelier to show healthier

bottom lines .

Air pollution in recent years has become one of the more serious

environmental concerns because of the many implications involved. The problem

has reached a degree of considerable concern, however because of the lack of

political will to attack the problem in a radical manner (because of the

economic distortions it would create) a market oriented alternative must be

approached. There are many areas which need to be addressed so as to develop a

comprehensive pollution reduction program. All sources of air pollution

(industrial, home and vehicle) must be taken into account when dealing with the

problem. However, by introducing environmentally friendly concepts such as

Emission Credit Trading a serious reduction in air pollution can be achieved,

and the initial steps toward the ecosociety taken. Obviously this is not the

ideal, having to put a price on the air we breath so as to ensure it’s quality,

but unfortunately it is the most viable option considering the social system in

which we all live.

Works Cited

1. Arnopoulos, P. Political Dimensions of an Information Society: A General

Overview. Montreal: Gamma,

1982.

2. Bryner, G. ed. Global Warming and the Challenge of International

Cooperation: An Interdisciplinary Assessment. Provo UT: Bringham Young

University Press, 1992.

3. Gore, A. Biotechnology: Implications for Public Policy. Washington DC. :

Brookings Institution, 1985.

4. Keller, E. Environmental Geology. Columbus: CE Merrill Publishing Co., 1985.

5. Mitchell, B. Canadian Resource Policies: Problems and Prospects. Toronto:

Methuen, 1981.

6. Rifkin, E. Proteases and Biological Control. New York: Cold Spring Harbour

Laboratory, 1975.

7. Saunders, DA Reintegrating Fragmented Landscapes: Towards Sustainable

Production and Nature Conservation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1993.

8. Vig, N and Kraft, M. Environmental Policy in the 1990’s. Washington DC: C.Q.

Press, 1990.


Загрузить файл

Похожие страницы:

  1. Air Pollution And Politics Essay Research Paper

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    Steps Towards an Ecosociety: Dealing with ... the first steps in the development of an ecosociety. The ... altering their sales mix towards more fuel efficient vehicles. ... , DA Reintegrating Fragmented Landscapes: Towards Sustainable Production and Nature Conservation ...
  2. Business Law Essay Research Paper Dr H

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... and Convention were major early steps towards an effective international framework for commercial ... appears to be moving towards recognition of an international body of ... any time. This grudging approach towards arbitration agreements reflected a variety ...
  3. The 39 Steps Hitchcock Essay Research Paper

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... s symbolism. The Thirty-Nine Steps seems to have been heralded ... and gives substantial evidence towards Hitchcock being the outstanding ... and suspense. The Thirty-Nine Steps is a wonderful film that ... cage. The Thirty-Nine Steps is an outstanding ride of suspense ...
  4. An Unfair Working Enviroment Essay Research Paper

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... achievement (3) [and) women's inclination towards self disclosure and the deuelopment ... in the workplace. Obulously, Sharon stepped ouer the boundaries regarding interpersonal ... workplace directed towards women of position. Perhaps men under an attractiue woman ...
  5. What Light Can An Appreciation Of The

    Реферат >> Остальные работы
    ... few decades has seen an exceptional growth in ... revolutionised telecommunications to such an extent that the world ... phases internationalisation began with an expansion in foreign trading. ... formation of Eurodollars and steps towards European Monetary Union. All ...

Хочу больше похожих работ...

Generated in 0.0029010772705078